|

Michel Petrucciani: Turning Weakness into Strength

Michel Petrucciani: turning weakness into strength, portrait of the jazz pianist

“Sometimes I think someone upstairs saved me from being ordinary.”

— Michel Petrucciani

Michel Petrucciani (1962–1999) is one of the pianists I love most. For his groove, his huge sound, the joy he brought every time he sat at the piano. But what fascinates me isn’t only his playing. It’s two things he said. The first is the line above. The second: “I don’t believe in geniuses. I believe in hard work.” In this article I want to focus on these two ideas: how you turn a weakness into a strength, and why talent without work gets you nowhere. And then, what a pianist can take from his playing itself.

PORTRAIT — MICHEL PETRUCCIANI

  • Born: December 28, 1962, Orange, southern France, into a musical family of Italian descent
  • Health: born with osteogenesis imperfecta, a genetic condition that makes bones brittle. He grew to about one meter tall. His hands, however, were not affected
  • Training: eight years of classical piano. From age 9 he played in the family band with his father, a guitarist, and his brother, a bassist
  • Influences: Duke Ellington, whom he saw on TV as a child, and Bill Evans, whom he listened to from age 10
  • First steps: at 13 he played his first professional gig, with trumpeter Clark Terry
  • America: in 1982 saxophonist Charles Lloyd, who had withdrawn from performing, returned to the stage to play with him. Soon after, he became the first French musician signed to Blue Note
  • Died: January 6, 1999, New York, aged just 36. He is buried at Père Lachaise cemetery in Paris

Turning weakness into strength

As a small child he saw Duke Ellington on television and decided he wanted to be a pianist. At four he was given a toy piano. He smashed it with a little hammer; he wanted a real one. Years later he remembered that the keys looked like teeth, as if the piano were laughing at him, and that you had to be strong enough to make the piano feel little. “That took a lot of work,” he added.

His feet couldn’t reach the pedals, so his father built an extension. In his early concerts he had to be carried onto the stage. And yet he said that in certain respects his condition was an advantage: it kept him away from distractions like the sports other boys played. While they were out playing ball, he was at the piano.

“Sometimes I think someone upstairs saved me from being ordinary.”
— Michel Petrucciani, in The New Republic

That line isn’t consolation. It’s a way of thinking. It doesn’t ask “why me?” It asks “what can I do with what I have?”

In 30 years of teaching I often hear students list their own “weaknesses”: “my hands are small,” “I started late,” “I’m a classical player and can’t improvise,” “I don’t have time.” All of these are real. But none of them is a reason to stop. They are the starting point for designing your own practice.

AT THE PIANO: TURN YOUR WEAKNESS INTO A PLAN

  • Small hands: work on close voicings and Barry Harris voicings built on the 3rd and 7th. You don’t need tenths to sound rich.
  • Classical background: reading, articulation and finger control are assets. What’s missing is the ear and the swing, and those can be learned.
  • Little time: 20 focused minutes every day are worth more than three hours on Sunday.
  • You started late: an adult knows what they want to hear. That’s an advantage a child doesn’t have.

“I don’t believe in geniuses. I believe in hard work.”

Petrucciani was called a child prodigy early on. He rejected the word. His full statement says that ever since he was a child he knew what he wanted to do, and he worked for it.

You can see it in his path. Eight years of classical piano. From age 9 in the family band. At 13 on stage with Clark Terry. And even more striking: in February 1993, already famous, he asked his agent to cancel his trio dates for a year so he could play nothing but solo concerts. He believed that a pianist is not complete until he can play by himself, and he described that year as a time of discovering the piano and studying every night.

For me this is the most important lesson here. “Genius” is often the word we use so we don’t have to see how much work lies behind something. And when a student believes some people “have it” and others don’t, they usually quit early. Jazz can be learned. With method, patience and daily practice. More on that in my guide to how to practice jazz piano.

What a pianist can learn from his playing

Groove before speed

Petrucciani could play incredibly fast, but what wins you over is his rhythmic drive, the feeling that the music always moves forward. Guitarist John Abercrombie, who recorded with him, told NPR that Michel’s sense of swing was powerful. Listen to his left hand too: it doesn’t just comp chords. It plays rhythmic figures, syncopations, bass lines. He was a two-handed pianist in the literal sense. To work on swing systematically, see these swing feel exercises for piano.

The big sound

When Clark Terry saw the 13-year-old being carried onto the stage, he thought it was a joke. Once he heard him, he said he was small but played like a giant. Petrucciani’s sound was full, powerful, with big dynamic contrasts. Sound doesn’t come from the size of your body. It comes from how you use your weight, and from an ear that knows what it wants to hear.

From Bill Evans to his own voice

At first he sounded a lot like Bill Evans. When he moved to New York he stayed with drummer Barry Altschul, who gave him a piece of advice: every time you hear yourself play a Bill Evans phrase, change it. Within a while, as Altschul put it, he became “Michel.” That’s the right order: first you copy from records, because that’s how the language is learned (see my guide on how to transcribe jazz piano). Then you consciously change what you copied until it becomes yours.

Classical music in the service of jazz

In a 1998 interview with the French magazine L’Express he said he often listened to jazz pianists like Bill Evans, Erroll Garner and Art Tatum, and also to classical music. Not for interpretation, for composition. He borrowed ideas mostly from Ravel, Debussy and Rachmaninov. His classical training shows in the clarity of his articulation and the control of his right hand. He never treated it as the enemy of jazz.

Music as communication and joy

In the same interview he describes the best moments of a concert: a rhythm takes over, and the artist, the audience, the piano and the room become one. It’s no longer him playing, it’s the audience. And he said that when he plays, he plays not to people’s heads but to their hearts. I believe this deeply: technique serves communication, not display.

At the piano: two exercises in the spirit of Petrucciani

1. THE ALTSCHUL EXERCISE

  1. Take a phrase you’ve transcribed from your favorite pianist.
  2. Play it exactly as it is, until it’s in your fingers and your ear.
  3. Change one thing at a time: the rhythm, the starting note, where it lands in the bar, the ending.
  4. Keep the version you like best. Now it’s yours.

2. A LEFT HAND THAT GROOVES

  1. Choose a standard you know well.
  2. In the left hand play shell voicings (root with 3rd or 7th), but not on the beats. Play them on the “and” of 2 and the “and” of 4, as anticipations.
  3. In the right hand play only the melody, simply.
  4. Once the left hand is steady, start improvising with the right without letting the left lose its groove. Start with the metronome on 2 and 4.

Where to start: 5 recordings

  • Pianism (Blue Note, 1985): his trio in top form, one of his first Blue Note albums
  • Power of Three (Blue Note, 1986): live with Wayne Shorter and Jim Hall
  • Michel Plays Petrucciani (Blue Note, 1987): his own compositions
  • Promenade with Duke (Blue Note, 1993): solo piano dedicated to Ellington, the pianist who made him want to play
  • Solo Live (Dreyfus, recorded 1997): live in Frankfurt, all his groove and energy alone at the piano

Watch him play: “Caravan”

Here you can hear everything we’ve talked about: the left hand holding the groove, the huge sound, the joy. Petrucciani plays “Caravan” solo, a tune from the repertoire of Duke Ellington, the pianist who made him want to play. Notice how often the left hand lands just before the beat rather than on it.

Watch the film

If you want to meet the man behind the music, watch Michel Petrucciani – Body & Soul by Michael Radford (2011), screened at Cannes. It’s an honest film, light and shadow included, with lots of music and interviews with the people who knew him.

What we keep from Michel Petrucciani

  • Your weakness isn’t the end of the conversation. It’s the starting point of your plan.
  • There are no geniuses. There is work, every day.
  • Groove comes before speed.
  • Sound comes from the ear and your weight, not your size.
  • Copy the greats, then change what you copied until it’s yours.
  • Play to the listener’s heart, not their head.

That’s why in my online lessons we don’t use ready-made recipes. We start from where you are, with your strengths and your difficulties, and build a method tailored to you, from beginner to advanced.

Sources

Jazz Piano Newsletter

The next article, in your inbox

About once a month: new articles, practice ideas and free material on jazz piano and the Barry Harris method. No spam, one-click unsubscribe.

Subscribe
CM

Christos Mastrogiannidis

Jazz Pianist & Educator · Berklee College of Music · Kunst Universität Graz · 30 years of teaching the Barry Harris method

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *